Report comment

Sorry this is a long post but it is very important that you read this and take in what I am saying. Especially because you who are involved with diagnosis are paid very highly indeed.
UMESH PRABHU,
Medicine in NOT an ART it is a branch of Engineering Science. Diagnosis is a skill that can be learned by trial and error and experience to some degree but it can also be taught. The medical profession could learn a considerable amount from other branches of engineering which use diagnostic techniques and actually teach diagnostics/fault finding a subject in its own right. Electronic engineering being one of many.
For instance have you heard of the "Half Split Method"? if not ask yourself why not?

I have been misdiagnosed several times by doctors who obviously do not understand how the human body works. Before you can diagnose anything you have to have a very good understanding of how it is supposed to work. In total.

How many GPs know anything about "backs" for example. If a patient has a back problem they just don't want to know but the spine and spinal cord is a vital part of the working body connecting arguably the most vital organ the BRAIN to the rest of the body.
In my case I am very unhappy with the number of times my symptoms have been misdiagnosed so here follows just some of my personal bad experiences with the NHS.

1. I had a detached ligament in my lower back diagnosed as lower back pain and was sent to physiotherapy and given various exercises which made it worse. in the end I had to self diagnose and I decided to totally rest my back and not even bend over for 5 days which allowed the ligament to reattach and heal perfectly, FIXED FOREVER no problems since.

2. I have had attacks of rapid heart rate intermittently for 35 years and never diagnosed despite going to the GP many times. And guess what? There is a recording device that I could have been given to take with me at all times and record the attacks as they happened. So the excuse that the attacks could not be recorded was incorrect. I have recently had a heart attack due to this condition which I was told was harmless despite no diagnosis. It could have been avoided if only I had been diagnosed properly. I am very annoyed to say the least.

3. I went back into hospital with chest pain and spent 5 days in agony at times and on oxygen only to be discharged with "NON SPECIFIC CHEST PAIN".
What sort of diagnosis is that?
I self diagnosed myself from my symptoms and by using GOOGLE. I had pericarditis. This was made worse by lying on my back in a hospital bed and eased by sitting, leaning forward.
My GP said pericarditis was unlikely because it is rare. However after 5 days in a cardiac ward without an answer I would have thought that any logical person would be looking for a rare condition! Just because something is rare does not mean a patient can not have it!

What an unusual story you might think. But no, I hear the same complaints from everyone I meet who has had the pleasure of going to the GP or having NHS hospital treatment.
If the condition is trivial like a broken finger then fine, but anything more complicated is a "We don't know" or "No one knows what the cause is" even though a bit of careful detective work and understanding of the human body would provide an answer to the cause in many cases.

Treat the cause, not the symptoms.

Take it from me as a person experienced in advanced diagnostic techniques, NHS, you are ****. I am sure you can fill in the letters to make an appropriate word to describe how bad you are at diagnosing ailments.
So you are very right to have this discussion, you might just learn something at last.