• Skip to main content
  • Skip to navigation
  • HSJ
  • HSJ Intelligence
  • HSJ Best Practice
Return to home page
HSJ logo
HSJ
Steve Black

Why lobby groups’ claims need careful scrutiny

Mast navigation
  • Register
  • Sign In
  • Subscribe
Search our site
Menu
Close menu
  • Home
    • Back to parent navigation item
    • Home
    • News
    • Daily Insight
    • Expert Briefings
    • CEO Interviews
    • HSJ Health Check podcast
    • HSJ Solutions - NHS Best Practice Database
  • Ask HSJ
  • Sectors
    • Back to parent navigation item
    • Sectors
    • Integrated care
    • Acute care
    • Primary care
    • Community services
    • Mental health
    • Emergency care
  • Topics
    • Back to parent navigation item
    • Topics
    • Finance and efficiency
    • Quality and performance
    • Workforce
      • Back to parent navigation item
      • Workforce
      • People Moves
    • Policy and regulation
    • Service redesign
    • Technology and innovation
    • Patient safety
    • Health inequalities
  • Local
    • Back to parent navigation item
    • Local
    • Providers
    • Regions
    • ICBs
  • Comment
    • Back to parent navigation item
    • Comment
    • Julian Patterson
    • National Voices 'takeover'
    • National Care Forum collection
  • Interactive
  • Events
  • Jobs
    • Back to parent navigation item
    • Jobs
    • Search HSJjobs
    • Leadership Q&A
    • People Moves
    • Courses
  • All Products
    • Back to parent navigation item
    • All Products
    • Subscription Options
      • Back to parent navigation item
      • Subscription Options
      • HSJ Expert Briefings
      • CEO Interviews
    • Team Access
    • HSJ Membership
    • HSJ Best Practice - Search NHS best practice
    • HSJ Intelligence - Insight for NHS Suppliers
      • Back to parent navigation item
      • HSJ Intelligence - Insight for NHS Suppliers
      • What is HSJ Intelligence
      • HSJ Intelligence
    • HSJ Jobs
    • HSJ Events
    • About Us
      • Back to parent navigation item
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
      • HSJ App
    • Subscription FAQs
  • Subscribe
  • HSJ
  • HSJ Intelligence
  • HSJ Best Practice
  • Home
      • News
      • Daily Insight
      • Expert Briefings
      • CEO Interviews
      • HSJ Health Check podcast
      • HSJ Solutions - NHS Best Practice Database
    • steve black
      The mythbuster: The claims of professional lobby groups need careful scrutiny
    • Hsj catchup 3x2
      HSJ Weekly Catch-up: Maternity, mergers and the NHSE exodus
    • Hsj daily insight logo
      Daily Insight: The NHSE brain drain
  • Ask HSJ
  • Sectors
      • Integrated care
      • Acute care
      • Primary care
      • Community services
      • Mental health
      • Emergency care
    • O'Donnell
      I was told to close down 4,000 safety reports, claims manager
    • Victoria-Tzortziou-Brown-RCGP-570x380
      Slow down shift to neighbourhoods, says GP leader
    • Contract 3x2
      First trusts win IHO status
  • Topics
      • Finance and efficiency
      • Quality and performance
      • Workforce
        • People Moves
      • Policy and regulation
      • Service redesign
      • Technology and innovation
      • Patient safety
      • Health inequalities
    • O'Donnell
      I was told to close down 4,000 safety reports, claims manager
    • Victoria-Tzortziou-Brown-RCGP-570x380
      Slow down shift to neighbourhoods, says GP leader
  • Local
      • Providers
      • Regions
      • ICBs
  • Comment
      • Julian Patterson
      • National Voices 'takeover'
      • National Care Forum collection
    • Finance report documents
      NHS management consultants need recognition and support
    • Barbara Harpham, chair, Medical Technology Group (MTG)
      If ‘value’ is to have a greater role in buying decisions, we first need to measure it
    • Resham Kotecha
      Without better data, the NHS will squander the opportunities offered by AI
  • Interactive
    • Interactive
      HSJ Partners
      Webinars
      Roundtables
      Video podcasts
      Immersive Features
      Top leader lists
      HSJ Download Podcast
      HSJ Health Check Podcast
       
  • Events
    • Our Events
      Congress
      Forums
      Summits
      All Events

      Our Awards
      HSJ Awards
      Partnership
      Digital
      Patient Safety
      All Awards

      Our Webinars
      All Webinars


      28/09/2026 - 29/09/2026
      Telford

      The HSJ Patient Safety Congress brings together over 1000 attendees with the shared goal of pushing the boundaries of patient safety in the UK. Hear from patient advocates on an equal platform and leave with practical ideas to take back to your organisation.


      18/03/2027
      London

      ENTRIES OPEN UNTIL 11 SEPT

      The Awards celebrates and showcases those collaborations and partnerships driving transformation and improving patient outcomes across the NHS.


      18/03/2027
      London

      ENTRIES OPEN UNTIL 11 SEPT

      The Awards recognise and celebrate the invaluable contributions of independent healthcare providers to the NHS.
  • Jobs
      • Search HSJjobs
      • Leadership Q&A
      • People Moves
      • Courses

    • Find your next career
      move with HSJ

      cv illustration

      Search vacancies, upload your CV and get jobs by email

      Discover our job
      advertising opportunities

      HSJ Jobs Adverts

      Advertise standard listings to
      leadership packages and more.

  • All Products
      • Subscription Options
        • HSJ Expert Briefings
        • CEO Interviews
      • Team Access
      • HSJ Membership
      • HSJ Best Practice - Search NHS best practice
      • HSJ Intelligence - Insight for NHS Suppliers
        • What is HSJ Intelligence
        • HSJ Intelligence
      • HSJ Jobs
      • HSJ Events
      • About Us
        • Contact Us
        • HSJ App
      • Subscription FAQs
  • Subscribe

    • Individual Access

      Indi sub v2
      Get unrestricted access to breaking news and exclusive insight that can support you in your role in healthcare

      Team/Group Access

      HSJ Mockup
      Provide your teams with the information they need to lead your strategy and initiatives forward

      HSJ Membership

      HSJ Membership
      Find out about our advanced subscription package designed for NHS organisations
  • More from navigation items

Leadership

Latest

Victoria-Tzortziou-Brown-RCGP-570x380

Slow down shift to neighbourhoods, says GP leader

2026-07-20T03:43:00+01:00By Caitlin Tilley

Plans to introduce neighbourhood provider contracts next year should be “reconsidered”, the Royal College of GPs’ president has told HSJ.

  • Mark_Hackett

    ICB CEO temporarily steps down after three months

  • Emily Miles

    CQC names new CEO

  • Addenbrooke's Hospital

    ‘Lives destroyed for speaking up’ at top hospital, claim doctors

  • Lyn Simpson

    Single CEO candidate shortlisted after governors demanded competition

  • 16 trusts ‘streamlined’ towards advanced FT status

  • CEO warns against ‘top slicing’ acutes for ‘well meaning’ neighbourhood schemes

  • Trust appoints substantive CEO five weeks after hiring interim

  • ‘Failure to deliver reforms has cost NHS billions’, claims ex-DHSC adviser

  • New role for ‘culture reset’ chief

  • Mackey issues 10-point ‘urgent’ maternity plan

  • ICB boss to lead regional team

  • Behave properly or leave, trust tells staff

  • Behaviour concerns ‘swept under carpet’ at struggling trust

  • ‘Attractiveness’ of ‘underpaid’ chair roles under review

Comment

  • Farhat Gull

    Clinical AI tools need to prioritise confidence, not speed

  • Roger Kline

    The Mann Review will not help NHS leaders tackle racism

  • Victor Adebowale 2

    The NHS is getting better thanks to its leaders

  • Natalie Berry

    Political whim should not drive NHS restructures

  • Steven McMillan

    The benefits of slow leadership

  • Advertise
  • Awards
  • Events
  • Contact Us
  • Download the app
  • HSJ Partners
  • Membership
  • Subscribe
Connect with HSJ
  • Terms And Conditions
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sustainability & ESG Reporting
  • Subscriptions FAQ
  • © 2026 HSJ Information Ltd

Part of HSJ Information Ltd. 5th Floor, Aldgate Tower, 2 Leman Street, London E1 8FA. Registered in England and Wales. Company registration 2530185

Site powered by Webvision Cloud