The English waiting list is 20 per cent bigger than at the last general election but despite that, long waits have improved under the Coalition. We are now well into the zone where the ‘90 per cent adjusted admitted’ target is at risk
For the first time since March 2008 there are officially more than 3 million patients on the English waiting list, according to the latest figures - May 2014 - just released.
In fact, because of data revisions, it turns out there were over 3 million back in April too which means it turns out I was wrong to tick off the Labour Party for calling it last month.
Three million is not just a nice round number, it is the start of the danger zone for breaching the high profile target that 90 per cent of admitted patients should have waited less than 18 weeks - though the target was actually met in May.
‘May waiting times pretty much undid whatever happened in April’
On past form we can expect the list to carry on growing for another couple of months, but only by about 100,000 patients. This takes us well into the admitted patient danger zone, but below the next danger point at around 3.3 million where the incomplete pathways target would be at risk too. There is also the £250m elective care fund, which should hold the list size down a bit more than in recent years.
Other than the headline list size, the story in May was of waiting times converging on 18 weeks. Those specialties and services that were breaching the “incomplete pathways” 18 weeks target got better, and those that were comfortably within the target got worse.
In short, May pretty much undid whatever happened in April.
- Surgeons call for review of 18 week waiting target
- Findlay: English waiting times step back from the brink
- Elective waiting list at its longest in six years
- Elective waiting list continues to grow
In the following analysis, all figures come from NHS England. If you have a national statistic that you’d like to check up on, you can download our NHS waiting times fact checker. So if you hear any commentary about how much waiting times have worsened since the Coalition came into power, you can check up on the figures - hint: they haven’t.
The picture England wide
The waiting list grew, as it usually does at this time of year, and by the usual amount.
What is significant is:
- it takes us past 3 million to the largest list size since February 2008; and
- we are now well into the zone where the “90 per cent adjusted admitted” target is at risk - though it was not breached in May.
Admissions were slightly higher than in previous years, which is helpful but plainly not enough.
We need to be shrinking this waiting list, by raising activity so that it exceeds demand.
Long waits got slightly worse in May, but remain much better than they were a couple of years ago.
They are also - despite what you might hear in the media - much better than they were at the last general election in May 2010, even though the total list has grown 20.3 per cent since then.
‘The Coalition has consolidated and improved on Labour’s success since it came to power’
Thus the number of over 18 week waiters on the list is down 7.5 per cent since the last election, over 26 week waiters are down 35.2 per cent, over 39 week waiters are down 75.3 per cent, and over 52 week waiters are down 96.9 per cent.
This is not to detract from the astonishing success of the last Labour government’s drive to achieve 18 week referral to treatment waiting times, but to show that the Coalition has consolidated and improved on that success since it came to power.
Thanks, I would say, to the increased attention they have paid to the waiting list (incomplete pathways).
The overall picture on my favourite summary measure is that the improvements in April have been undone in May.
At specialty level the reversals continue. Specialties that got worse in April improved in May, and vice versa.
At the same time they converged on 18 weeks; the worst improved and the best declined.
The exception is Urology, which continued its long slow decline and started breaching 18 weeks for the first time since March 2012.
The proportion of specialties at provider level - achieving the 92 per cent incomplete pathways target - remained steady. But the distribution changed.
Again we can see that those services that were breaching got better, and those that were inside the target got worse.
If this carries on, it will look like the NHS is treating “18 weeks” literally as a “target” to be hit as accurately as possible, instead of a backstop to remain comfortably below.
Not a lot of change in this month’s table, except that Great Western Hospitals Foundation Trust have popped up from nowhere - well, 83rd place - to number eighth on our table, with a whopping 56 one year breaches.
Perhaps they have found some patients that weren’t previously being reported; if that’s the case, well done them for coming clean, and now that they know about those patients, they can get them treated quickly.
‘Well done to the trusts that did not report for coming clean; now they can get them treated quickly’
Five trusts did not report their waiting lists: Barking, Havering and Redbridge University Hospitals Trust, Barnet and Chase Farm Hospitals Trust, Tameside Hospital Foundation Trust, Walsall Healthcare Trust and Whittington Hospital Trust.
This means that Derby Hospitals Foundation Trust has returned to reporting data after installing their new IT system: well done.
Congratulations to five trusts for dropping out of the table: Taunton and Somerset Foundation Trust, Alder Hey Children’s Foundation Trust - just, Heatherwood and Wexham Park Hospitals Foundation Trust, Cumbria Partnership Founation Trust, and Oxford University Hospitals Trust.
Data for June 2014 is due out at 9:30am on 7 August.
Rob Findlay is founder of Gooroo Ltd and a specialist in waiting time dynamics
- ALDER HEY CHILDREN'S FOUNDATION TRUST
- BARKING, HAVERING AND REDBRIDGE UNIVERSITY HOSPITALS NHS TRUST
- BARNET AND CHASE FARM HOSPITALS NHS TRUST
- East Midlands
- Emergency care
- Government/DH policy
- GREAT WESTERN HOSPITALS NHS FOUNDATION TRUST
- HEATHERWOOD AND WEXHAM PARK HOSPITALS NHS FOUNDATION TRUST
- North Cumbria Integrated Care NHS Foundation Trust
- Oxford University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
- Primary care
- South Central
- TAMESIDE HOSPITAL NHS FOUNDATION TRUST
- TAUNTON AND SOMERSET NHS FOUNDATION TRUST
- University Hospitals of Derby and Burton NHS Foundation Trust
- WALSALL HEALTHCARE NHS TRUST
- Whittington Health NHS Trust