- Eight English trusts and three Welsh health boards among those breaching health and safety law
- Issues raised include protecting staff from violence and aggression, asbestos control and handling of sharp instruments
- Further 18 providers broke health and safety law but were not issued enforcement notices
NHS providers were given 40 official warnings because regulators believed they were failing to protect staff from violence, injury and hazardous substances in the past two years, HSJ can reveal.
The Health and Safety Executive issued 38 improvement or prohibition notices in 2018-19 and 2019-20 to providers in England and Wales, which were breaking health and safety laws.
HSE found providers had failed to follow laws aimed at protecting staff from issues such as violence and aggression, injuries from manual handling, asbestos and hazardous substances.
Eight English trusts and three Welsh health boards received the notices — which either set deadlines for improvements or outlined activity which should be banned — during the time period.
HSJ reported last month that around two-thirds of NHS providers inspected by HSE since April 2018 – 21 of 38 providers inspected – were found to be breaking laws aimed at protecting staff from violence and aggression.
Through a freedom of information request, HSJ has obtained details of the health and safety law breaches which HSE deemed serious enough to warrant enforcement notices. The full list is below.
A further 18 providers in England and Scotland were also found to have broken the law in the period but were not served enforcement notices from HSE.
Welsh health boards Abertawe Bro Morgannwg University Health Board and Hywel Dda UHB had the most enforcement notices in the period, with nine and eight respectively.
Mental health trust Hertfordshire Partnership University Foundation Trust received four improvement notices in 2019-20 — the highest number received by any English trust. HSE told the trust it was breaking the law in relation to violence and aggression risk assessments and investigation arrangements, as well as manual handling.
Meanwhile, two prohibition notices were served to United Lincolnshire Hospitals FT in 2019-20 relating to asbestos. The trust noted in board papers last Decemberthe presence of asbestos was limiting maintenance works at Lincoln County Hospital, and some areas of the trust were sealed off due to the issue.
HSE declined to provide precise reasons beyond a general description of the notice as to why each provider had broken the law, citing an exemption in the FOI act for information held about certain investigations or proceedings.
However, Leeds Community Healthcare FT, which was found to be breaking the law on violence and aggression and manual handling but did not receive an enforcement notice, published its notice of contravention from the HSE in its board papers in December.
HSJ approached all providers which received enforcement notices from HSE for comment.
Providers which received enforcement notices
Countess of Chester Hospital FT
Improvement notices: Two for violence and aggression policies, one for manual handling. The notices related to caring for people with dementia.
The trust said the inspectors have since signed off the notices.
Bradford District Care FT
Improvement notices: One for violence and aggression policies.
North Middlesex University Hospital Trust
Improvement notices: One for the control of hazardous substances.
The trust said the notice related to risks of contact dermatitis — a type of eczema — among theatre staff due to their need to frequently wash their hands, use cleansers and skin scrubs, rubber gloves and sanitisers and detergents. It said it has provided evidence to HSE it is reducing this risk.
Hertfordshire Partnership University FT
Improvement notices: Two for violence and aggression policies, risk assessments and accident investigation arrangements, two for manual handling.
The trust said it has made “some immediate changes” and an action plan is in place.
East and North Hertfordshire Trust
Improvement notices: One for exposure to blood-borne viruses and to sharp instruments in healthcare, one for manual handling, and one for violence and aggression policies.
The trust said it is on track to be compliant by the end of April for violence and aggression and sharps, and by end of July for moving and handling.
United Lincolnshire Hospitals Trust
Improvement notices: One for asbestos in confined spaces.
Prohibition notices: One for asbestos in confined spaces, one for asbestos management.
The trust said the prohibition notices referred to how the maintenance team work in confined spaces in subways below its hospitals in areas not accessible to the public. It added it had provided training and equipment to ensure staff are safe.
Midlands Partnership FT
Improvement notices: Two for violence and aggression policies, one for manual handling.
The trust said it has taken action on the issues, such as training staff in de-escalation, management and intervention, and it was confident no one is at risk of harm.
Hywel Dda UHB
Improvement notices: Two for violence and aggression policies, four for manual handling, one for incident reporting arrangements and one for sharp instruments in healthcare.
The health board said it has developed an action plan to address the issues, which includes a training programme around challenging behaviours for clinical staff, improvements to manual handling procedures for moving medical records and laundry, and trialling lone working devices such as body-worn video equipment.
Bedford Hospital Trust
Improvement notices: One for manual handling.
The trust said the notice has now been removed after training sessions across the hospital were improved.
Powys Health Board
Improvement notices: Two for legionella.
Abertawe Bro Morgannwg UHB
Improvement notices: Nine for a range of violence and aggression and manual handling breaches.
The health board said it had been informed by HSE it has complied fully with all the notices.
Providers where a breach of the law was found, but no enforcement notice was issued
The HSE said the following providers breached health and safety law but were not given enforcement notices. The breaches included issues such as manual handling, lifting equipment, reporting of injuries, diseases and dangerous occurrences, fire precautions, hazardous substances, confined spaces and control of asbestos. HSE did not specify which breaches had happened at specific providers.
Leeds Community Healthcare Trust
Central and North West London FT
North West Anglia FT
East Sussex Healthcare Trust
Leicestershire Partnership Trust
Birmingham Community Healthcare Trust
Cornwall Partnership FT
Sheffield Health and Social Care Partnership FT
Leeds and York Partnership FT
Gateshead Health FT
Camden and Islington FT
St George’s University Hospitals FT
Cambridge and Peterborough FT
Kent and Medway NHS and Social Care Partnership Trust
Avon and Wiltshire Mental Health Partnership Trust
Royal Cornwall Hospitals Trust
HSJ Provider Summit
The HSJ Provider Summit, taking place at the Crowne Plaza, Stratford-upon-Avon from 22-23 April 2020, unites 120+ board members from provider trusts across the country with those shaping national policy, to share best-in-class initiatives in delivering cost-effective and high-quality care for their local populations.
Held under the Chatham House Rule, attendees will co-develop solutions to their local challenges with colleagues from across the country. The summit is free to attend for board-level NHS leaders.
Information provided to HSJ
- AVON AND WILTSHIRE MH PARTNERSHIP NHS TRUST
- BEDFORD HOSPITAL NHS TRUST
- Birmingham Community Healthcare NHS Trust
- BRADFORD DISTRICT CARE NHS TRUST
- CAMBRIDGESHIRE AND PETERBOROUGH FOUNDATION TRUST
- CAMDEN AND ISLINGTON NHS FOUNDATION TRUST
- CENTRAL AND NORTH WEST LONDON MH NHS TRUST
- CORNWALL PARTNERSHIP NHS FOUNDATION TRUST
- COUNTESS OF CHESTER HOSPITAL NHS FOUNDATION TRUST
- EAST AND NORTH HERTFORDSHIRE NHS TRUST
- EAST SUSSEX HEALTHCARE NHS TRUST
- GATESHEAD HEALTH NHS FOUNDATION TRUST
- Hertfordshire Partnership University NHS Foundation Trust
- KENT AND MEDWAY NHS AND SOCIAL CARE PARTNERSHIP NHS TRUST
- Leeds and York Partnership NHS Foundation Trust
- Leeds Community Healthcare NHS Trust
- LEICESTERSHIRE PARTNERSHIP NHS TRUST
- Midlands Partnership NHS Foundation Trust
- NORTH MIDDLESEX UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL NHS TRUST
- North West Anglia NHS Foundation Trust
- Patient safety
- Quality and performance
- ROYAL CORNWALL HOSPITALS NHS TRUST
- SALISBURY NHS FOUNDATION TRUST
- Sheffield Health & Social Care NHS Foundation Trust
- St George’s University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
- Staff wellbeing
- UNITED LINCOLNSHIRE HOSPITALS NHS TRUST