Analysis of the best and worst performers in the North of England region on key measures in the NHS staff survey 2015, released today.

Recommending care to friends and family

We looked at the proportion of staff who disagreed with the statement: “If a friend or relative needed treatment I would be happy with the standard of care provided by this organisation.”

We excluded ambulance provider trusts from this analysis, as they generally have substantially worse performance. All other provider trust types are included.

Worst performers: 10 trusts with the biggest proportion disagreeing

 Disagree or strongly disagree (%)
Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust 28
Mid Yorkshire Hospitals Trust 23
North Cumbria University Hospitals Trust 22
Northern Lincolnshire and Goole Foundation Trust 17
Southport And Ormskirk Hospital Trust 15
Leeds and York Partnership Foundation Trust 14
Rotherham Foundation Trust 14
Pennine Acute Hospitals Trust 14
Warrington and Halton Hospitals Foundation Trust 13
Hull and East Yorkshire Hospitals Trust 13

Best performers: 10 trusts with the smallest proportion disagreeing

The best performers reflect the common trend for specialist providers to perform well in the staff survey, but there are also some general acute and community health service trusts with strong results, including Northumbria and Harrogate.

 Disagree or strongly disagree (%)
The Christie Foundation Trust 1
Liverpool Heart and Chest Hospital Foundation Trust 2
Sheffield Children’s Foundation Trust 3
The Walton Centre Foundation Trust 3
The Clatterbridge Cancer Centre Foundation Trust 3
The Newcastle Upon Tyne Hospitals Foundation Trust 3
Salford Royal Foundation Trust 4
Northumbria Healthcare Foundation Trust 4
Harrogate and District Foundation Trust 5
Liverpool Women’s Foundation Trust 5

Are there enough staff?

We looked at the proportion of staff who disagreed with the statement: “There are enough staff at this organisation for me to do my job properly.”

We excluded ambulance provider trusts from this analysis, as they generally have substantially worse performance. All other provider trust types are included.

Worst performers: 10 trusts with the biggest proportion disagreeing

 Disagree and strongly disagree (%)
Leeds Community Healthcare Trust 65
Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust 59
Mid Yorkshire Hospitals Trust 59
North Cumbria University Hospitals Trust 58
Calderdale and Huddersfield Foundation Trust 57
Humber Foundation Trust 57
Bridgewater Community Healthcare Foundation Trust 56
Alder Hey Children’s Foundation Trust 56
Bradford Teaching Hospitals Foundation Trust 53
Mersey Care Trust 53

Best performers: 10 trusts with the smallest proportion disagreeing

The best performers reflect the common trend for specialist providers to perform well in the staff survey, but there are also some general acute and community health service trusts with strong results, including Wrightington, Wigan and Leigh FT and Northumbria; and mental health providers including Tees, Est and Wear Valleys.

 Disagree and strongly disagree (%)
Wrightington, Wigan and Leigh Foundation Trust 29
Liverpool Heart and Chest Hospital Foundation Trust 32
Tees, Esk and Wear Valleys Foundation Trust 33
The Christie Foundation Trust 33
The Walton Centre Foundation Trust 35
St Helens and Knowsley Hospitals Trust 38
Northumbria Healthcare Foundation Trust 38
Northumberland, Tyne and Wear Foundation Trust 39
South West Yorkshire Partnership Foundation Trust 39
The Clatterbridge Cancer Centre Foundation Trust 41