Nearly half of all nurses believe their organisation is at risk of becoming the “next Mid Staffs” or heading that way already, reveals the latest large-scale survey on NHS staffing levels.

The findings suggest many nursing teams are operating at danger point, with ongoing shortages damaging patient care, according to a Unison poll reported by HSJ’s sister title Nursing Times.

The union carried out the poll of nearly 3,000 nursing staff on 4 March to show a typical “day in the life” of the NHS.

The union’s head of nursing, Gail Adams, said: “It is a unique insight through the looking glass into what it’s really like and what they are telling us is that it is bloody tough.”

As part of the survey, staff were asked to evaluate their organisation against the care failings at Mid Staffordshire Foundation Trust.

A worrying 31 per cent said there was a risk of a similar situation developing, with 17 per cent claiming it had already happened in all or parts of their organisation.

Only 7 per cent said they were “very confident” a similar situation would never happen at their organisation, while just over 32 per cent said they were “fairly confident”.

“On occasions, staffing levels are bordering on dangerous,” said one nurse who took part. “We are in a Mid Staffs situation and I don’t believe we are the only ones.”

“What they are telling us is that it is bloody tough”

Gail Adams

The results mirror those from a survey carried out by Nursing Times in February to mark one year since the publication of the Francis report.

The Nursing Times survey of around 500 nurses found more than half believed their ward or unit remained dangerously understaffed 12 months after the seminal report into Mid Staffordshire Foundation Trust.

Unison said it had shared its survey findings – published in a report titled Running on Empty – with the Care Quality Commission to help potentially pinpoint individual organisations where staffing levels could be putting patients at risk.

The survey also found 45 per cent of nurses were caring for eight or more patients, which went up to 53 per cent for those working night shifts.

“The majority looking after eight or more were in medicine, surgery and elderly care, so we’re talking about patients that are quite vulnerable and whose dependency can be quite significant,” said Ms Adams.

Gail Adams

“Research that’s been around for the last two to three years tells us that if you are looking after eight or more patients then harm is occurring,” she said.

“You’d have hoped that research would have informed practice and workforce planning.”

This is the third time Unison has carried out the survey, and Ms Adams said one of the most frustrating findings was that so little had changed since the previous year – despite a new focus on safe staffing since the Francis report.

When asked if there were enough staff to deliver safe, dignified, compassionate care, 60 per cent of nurses said “no” and 31 per cent said “yes” – mirroring last year’s result.  

In addition, 65 per cent of nurses said they did not have enough time with patients with 55 per cent reported care was left undone as a result.

“We are in a Mid Staffs situation and I don’t believe we are the only ones”

Survey respondent

This is despite the fact 58 per cent worked through breaks or beyond the end of their shift.

A further 45 per cent said they had worked for up to an hour unpaid, while 10 per cent said they had worked up to two hours past the time they were supposed to finish.

The research also highlighted continuing reliance on bank and agency staff, with 45 per cent reporting they had worked alongside one or more bank or agency workers on the day of the survey.

In addition, 80 per cent said their employer frequently used bank or agency staff, a third of whom said this was because of chronic short staffing problems.

The survey report includes a series of recommendations, including calling for the creation of staffing level standards that would be legally enforced.

Failing that, Unison wants mandatory minimum nurse to patient ratios to be set nationally, which should be somewhere between one-to-four and one-to-six in certain types of wards.

The survey found almost 92 per cent of respondents support minimum staffing levels, with 65 per cent in favour of a legally enforceable minimum.

“We think nurses should be automatically reporting incidents where they are looking after eight or more patients or where they can’t deliver the standard  that’s required,” said Ms Adams.

She said another concerning finding from the survey was the fact nurses were still reluctant to raise concerns. Half reported not feeling confident in doing so.

Unison

Infographic based on a Unison staffing survey, carried on 4 March 2014

Exclusive: Review set to probe standard of nurse training