- 14-day isolation for covid-contacts in hospitals is “causing devastation”
- UKHSA and NHSE looking at the issue
- Major concern about general and acute bed capacity with omicron, winter and staff absences
- A separate rule restricting care home admissions after an omicron outbreak is being reviewed regionally
Officials are under pressure to relax national guidance which is ‘crippling healthcare’ by taking large numbers of beds out of action and blocking patient flow, HSJ has learned.
Infection prevention and control rules require contacts of confirmed covid cases in health and care settings to be isolated for 14 days, regardless of testing negative – even though contacts among the general public and staff are now subject to much more limited requirements if they test negative.
This was intended to prevent nosocomial spread of covid, which has caused many infections and deaths in previous waves.
However, very large numbers of omicron cases are being discovered in hospitals several days or more after admission, either because the virus was still incubating when they were tested on admission, or because it was caught in hospital, and is often not showing clear covid symptoms.
In these cases, while the confirmed-covid patient is moved to a room or covid-positive cohort, the remainder of the ward must also be isolated for 14 days. It means any remaining beds can’t be used and makes it very hard to move the patients within hospitals, and sometimes difficult to discharge them.
Several senior hospital clinicians with covid expertise said this was causing major problems and did not appear to be necessary.
It comes amid very high pressure on general and acute beds at many hospitals, as winter demand, omicron and staff absences combine, and are expected to grow further – with “covid surge hub” tents being erected outside several sites. Systems are scrambling to discharge as many people as possible in case omicron admissions surge.
HSJ understands the issue has been raised with the UK Health Security Agency, which oversees the national rules, and with NHS England national directors, and that senior officials are reviewing it.
Pat Cattini, an infection control nurse and former president of the Infection Prevention Society, said on Twitter: “While in hospital [contacts] have to be isolated for 14 days. This guidance has never changed despite vaccination and changing epidemiology and is crippling healthcare.”
She called for the issue to be reviewed “urgently” and said: “This is a huge driver of bed pressure.”
It causes a particular problem in older hospitals, such as those with large Nightingale wards, because more beds and a larger share of total capacity are affected.
A London hospital consultant said: “So many patients are turning positive at day one/two/three/four – admitted as non-covid but incubating covid – that it is causing devastation because of contacts and blocked beds.
“It is much, much harder to manage than delta due to [high] infectivity… [Trusts] need to adopt different strategies and make risk assessments.” It was contributing to hospitals “running out of both covid and non covid capacity”, the person said.
A senior hospital consultant in another region said: “It creates another major headache for bed management as it creates another stream of patients that have to be separated. Effectively what we are having to do now is create four hospitals within the hospital.” (For symptomatic respiratory covid, incidental covid, covid contacts, and non-covid).
The source added: “This headache grows when care homes won’t take patients back until they are out of the 14 day window which delays discharge.” Several sources said while it was permitted to discharge contacts within the 14 days, it was often difficult or impossible because of local objections.
A UKHSA spokesperson, asked about the issue, said: “The current guidance is in place to help limit the spread of covid-19 to vulnerable people and NHS staff. We continue to work in partnership with NHSEI to review the guidance and will make changes where appropriate.”
Regions move to relax rule which shuts down care home admission
Meanwhile, another national IPC rule which says care homes should usually not admit people for 28 days after an omicron outbreak has finished is also being reviewed. There have been concerns that it is significantly restricting care capacity – but strict rules are in place to limit harm from omicron in social care, where there were huge numbers of covid deaths in the spring 2020 wave.
A letter seen by HSJ from UKHSA chief Jenny Harries and Association of Directors of Public Health president Jim McManus, sent to local public health directors on 24 December, said the 28 days rule would remain in place, but stressed there was “local flexibility” for public health directors to decide to overrule it in their patch in exceptional circumstances.
The letter says: “We have also started to see an increase in outbreaks in care homes… Uncertainty about the severity and impact of omicron remains and we have not yet completed the roll-out of our booster programme in care homes and we are therefore continuing to recommend a defensive approach at a national level.
“However, this risk will need to be balanced against other risks to individuals and the wider health and social care system. Decisions on the timely discharge, from hospital to care homes, where that would both support residents’ recovery and contribute to easing hospital capacity are a consideration in this.”
It continues: “There is already local flexibility within government guidance to allow for residents to be safely admitted to a care home including when the care home is under outbreak restrictions. Local public health teams and [public health directors] should take a risk-based approach to considering where there could be flexibility to allow care homes to open up to admissions sooner than 28 days.”
HSJ understands London DpPH have now collectively reduced the period to 14 days, to help free up discharges, and that several other regions are also considering making similar changes.
Downloads
Joint letter from UKHSA CEX and ADPH Pres
PDF, Size 0.16 mb
7 Readers' comments